To me, it looks like the battery is not actually charging all the way. I would suggest taking it to a store and see if they can give you a new battery and, if that doesn't fix it, go back for a replacement phone.
If you want (and I don't know what your normal charging habits are) you could also try to fully charge the phone, use it until it is almost dead, then fully charge it. Maybe do this a few times to see if it is just a problem with the battery reporting.
We always want you to have a functional device Draggin86! Since you have had numerous replacements, have you considered reaching out to the manufacturer of the device for assistance? I recommend reaching out to Samsung by visiting http://bit.ly/IJvmpJ so they can review the issues that are occuring. Please keep us posted, thanks!
Follow us on Twitter @VZWSUPPORT
Just yesterday I got a new stellar we will see how this one works after being with out a phone for over a month. I recently filed a complaint with the better business bureau. Ive had numerous verizon associates neglect to return calls as promised or resolve this on going issue.
Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smartphone