Hello kquinn121, Congratulations on the new device! I hope you are enjoying it! Let's make sure you have all your data. Once shown the older date did you try to run another back up on the iPhone 4? To confirm, were you doing this while connected to your computer with the USB cable or through iCloud? Please keep me updated on the status as I would be more than happy to provide additional support.
Follow us on Twitter @VZWsupport