No, in order to use the BOGO offer you have to have two lines that are eligible for subsidized pricing. That means you need them both to either be new, or eligible to upgrade and sign a new contract.
You have to sign a new contract for every subsidized handset you get from Verizon.
I have saw several people discussing the BOGO on the droid but I can't find anywhere that mentions this am I just overlooking it? Could someone please post the link for this, I am eligible for an upgrade and am considering adding a line as well to my account so this would work well for me if I could find out more information about the BOGO.
Forget that last post, I finally found the BOGO offer I wasn't sure which droid phone it was on but found it.